Saturday, February 1, 2014

Study of psychiatric disorder in Nepal during political conflict (violent activities) C.P.Sedain1, MD, 1Assistant Professor, 2 Department of Psychiatry, CMSTH, Bharatpur, Nepal



Abstract

This study shows violent activity (political conflict) leading to many psychiatric disorders in Nepal. Among them commonest psychiatric disorder is depressive disorder (N-463,31.52%) Other psychiatric disorders associated violent activity in Nepal are conversion disorder (N-210,14.26%), Somatoform disorder (N-184,12.53%) and generalized anxiety  disorder (N-167,11.37%). Similarly post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), schizophrenia, mania, grief reaction, childhood depression, tension headache, and sleep disorder are also noticed and husband (parents) in foreign country is the leading cause of stress factors (N-576,39.21%).

Introduction
Psychiatric disorder is associated with different types of conflict in different parts of the world1.  Nepal has faced political conflict. Nepal is landlocked country surrounded by India in three directions and northern side is located by china. This study reflects the effect of political conflict on mental health in Nepal. This study shows that patients attending psychiatric department of College of Medical Science Bharatpur Chitwan,Nepal. This study shows mental illness which is linked with political conflict during the year 2004-2005 which is always important on the history of Nepal that brought big political changes. Now Nepal is on peace process. Because of political instability during 10 years period can be taken as “dark period” on the history of Nepal. During that period no any economic development works at all. The entire budget was kept on the police force and arm due to which it was very difficult to sustained for a land locked developing country2. Communist party “Maoist” took arms to cut down the autocratic regime which was supported by Seven Parties Alliance(SPA). During this period huge political awareness developed on Nepali people.                  
Nepal was suffered from violent activity 2052-2063 BS. The Maoist, one of the communist party started war with government demanding “Republic Nepal”. They started bullet war. Many thousands of people left Nepal and migrated in India and Gulf countries. People started to expose many  bad news like bomb blast, attack on barrack and district head office and “Nepal Banda” or strike and war etc. Because of bad news and death of many people by violent activity many Nepali developed mental illness. The “Revolution 2063” (B.S) which was biggest demonstration against the king which was successed by Seven Parties Alliance (SPA) and Nepal Communist Party Maoist (NCPM) which is very important on the history of Nepal. It is taken as major event on the world’s history, which bring “Loktantra” and kicked out  autocratic regime and open the door for constitutional assembly. About 13000 people sacrificed their life during 10 years people’s revolution.3
Objectives:
1)    To identify different psychiatric disorders that is related with violent activities.

2)    To identify stress factors related with psychiatric disorders.

 

Material and methods

The subjects for this study comprised of all consecutive patients associated with political conflict of Nepal which attended psychiatric Department of CMS Teaching Hospital Bharatpur Chitwan and Bharatpur jail were taken as case. The study was performed over 2 years (1st January 2004 to 30 th December 2005).A brief explanation about the study was offered to the subjects and written or verbal consent was obtained either from them or guardians and all the subjects   referred were included in the study.
A continuous sequential number was given to each subject and available necessary information was kept confidential in a separate file.The socio demographic profile which contains name, age, sex, caste, address, marital status, occupation, and other information also filled. The diagnosis was done on the basis of I.C.D. - 10 diagnostic research criteria (WHO, 1992).4

Results
Table-1
Distribution on the basis of age sex

AGE
Male
Female
Total
%
0-10
16
14
30
2.04
11-20
170
161
331
22.53
21-30
121
128
249
16.95
31-40
132
99
231
15.72
41-50
218
201
419
28.52
5-60
90
89
179
 12.19
61-70
19
11
30
2.04
TOTAL
766
703
1469
100

Table-1 shows highest numbers of patients were age group 41-50 (N-419, 28.52%) followed by age group11-20 (N-331, 22.53%). and most of cases were male (N-766,52.14%)






Table –2
Distribution on the basis of marital status

Marital status
N
%
Married
1035
70.46
Unmarried
358
24.37
Widow/widower
63
4.29
Total
1469
100

Table-2 shows highest numbers of patients were married (N-1035, 70.46%).

 

Table-3
Diagnosis of patients by using ICD-10 Diagnostic Research Criteria (ICD-10 DCR)

Diagnosis

Farmer
Political activist
Service holder
Police/army
Housewife
Unemployed
Total
%
Depressive disorder
231
116
39
42
31
4
463
31.52
PTSD
20
13
7
6
5
1
52
3.54
GAD
86
41
19
13
8
0
167
11.37
Schizophrenia
16
9
4
3
2
0
34
2.31
Acute psychosis
26
13
7
3
3
0
52
3.54
Conversion disorder
105
51
22
16
13
3
210
14.26
Mania
23
10
6
5
3
1
48
3.27
Grief reaction
18
9
5
1
1
2
36
2.45
Somatoform disorder
95
46
24
6
12
1
184
12.53
Child psychiatric disorder
45
0
0
0
0
51
76
5.17
 Tension Headache
51
26
13
6
0
0
96
6.54
Sleep Disorder
29
17
0
5
0
0
51
3.47
Total
725
351
146
106
78
63
1469
100

Legend

PTSD –Post Traumatic Stress Disorder
GAD –Generalized Anxiety Disorder
Tabel-3 shows distribution on the basis of diagnosis by using ICD-10, most of cases were diagnosed as depressive disorder (N-463, 31.52 % followed by conversion disorder N-210, 14.26). and most of cases were farmer (N-725, 49.35 %).

Table-4
Distribution on the basis of stress factors
Stress factors

Male
Female
Total
%
Husband/parent  in foreign country
0
576
576
39.21
Shifted  to foreign country for job
293
6
299
20.35
Death of parents/family member
83
19
102
6.94
Bomb blast
43
9
52
3.54
Ambus explosion
19
4
23
1.57
Bad news on tv/radio
138
58
196
13.34
Loss of job
119
3
122
8.30
Abduction
4
5
9
0.62
Turture
6
5
11
0.75
Nepal bandha
26
9
35
2.38
Bullet injury
14
2
16
1.09
Shifted to jail
21
7
28
1.91
Total
766
703
1469
100

Table-4 shows distribution on the basis of stress factors, most of cases were husbands/parents in foreign country (N-576, 39.21 %) followed by shifted to foreign country (N-299, 20.35 %)

Discussion:
This study shows that many people of Nepal were suffered with mental illness due to bad political condition i.e. violent activity (Political conflict)leading to many psychiatric disorder. Many thousands of people left Nepal and migrated in India and Gulf countries. People started to expose many to bad news like bomb blast, attack on barrack and district head office and “Nepal Banda” or strike and war etc. Because of bad news and death of many people by violent activity many Nepali developed mental illness. The samples were collected from 1-1-2004 to 30-12-05. This study shows that total numbers of psychiatric patients due to violent activities were 1469. The interview was taken and diagnosis was made by psychiatrist using ICD-10 diagnostic research criteria.
Study regarding psychiatric morbidity (Regmi et al, 1999) found that commonest psychiatric disorder was depressive disorder (N-451,31.45%)5. This study shows similar result in which the commonest psychiatric disorder leading to conflict was depressive disorder (N-463, 31.52%) Other psychiatric disorder associated violent activity in Nepal are conversion disorder (N-210,14.26%), Somatoform disorder (N-184,12.53%) and generalized disorder (167,11.37). Similarly post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), schizophrenia, mania, grief reaction, childhood depression, tension headache, and sleep disorder also noticed.
This study shows that  stress factors leading to psychiatric disorder related bad political situation during 2004-2005 are husbands (parents) in foreign country is the leading cause of stress factors (N-576,39.21%). Similarly shifted to foreign country (N-299, 20.35%) The period was danger period. Many people left job because of fear of forceful inclusion Maoist army. Some people left country because the army will give punishment. Another factor is that to get job on foreign country to get rid from poor financial condition. Similarly death of parents, bomb blast, ambush explosion, bad news on radio, bullet injury, Nepal Banda, loss of job and shifted to jail were the stress factors.    

References
1.       Vander-Knob, B. A.: Psychological trauma.  Washington DC, American Psychiatric press, 1987.
2.        Annual report: Department of Health Services Government of Nepal, Ministry of Health Kathmandu, 2003-2004,1,11-19.
3.        Bungert Martina: Psychosocial support for conflict affected children second international SAARCE Psychiatrists conference 2006,1,72-74.
4.        WHO: International Classification of disease and related heath problems, Tenth revision: Clinical description and diagnostic guideline; Geneva: World Health Organization. 1992.
5.       Regmi S.K et al,: A study of socio-demographic characteristics and diagnostic profile in psychiatric out patients of TUTH, Nepalese Journal of Psychiatry 1999, 1, 27-33.



                                                                                                                                                               

3 comments:

  1. Thanks for sharing this great article. Great information thanks a lot for the detailed article. That is very interesting I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this.
    bipolar disorder type i

    ReplyDelete
  2. You have a real ability for writing unique content. I like how you think and the way you represent your views in this article. I agree with your way of thinking. Thank you for sharing. counselling burnaby

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi, there. I am Tom Neil and I wish to describe how life had been for my younger brother living with schizophrenia and how he had been permanently able to overcome this debilitating disease via a naturopathic, herbal method.

    Maicon - my kid brother was twenty years old when he was brought to the emergency room by the campus police of the college from which he had been suspended several months ago. A professor had called and reported that he had walked into his classroom, accused him of taking his tuition money, and refused to leave.

    Although he had much academic success as a teenager, his behavior had become increasingly odd during the past year. He quit seeing his friends and no longer seemed to care about his appearance or social pursuits. He began wearing the same dress each day and seldom bathed. He lived with many family members but rarely spoke to any of them. When he did speak to them, he said he had found clues that his college was just a front for an organized crime operation. He had been suspended from college because of missing many classes. My sister said that she had often seen him mumbling quietly to himself and at times he seemed to be talking to people who were not there. He would emerge from my room and ask my family to be quiet even when they were not making any noise.

    My father and sister told the staff that Maicon's great-grandmother had had a serious illness and had lived for 30 years in a state hospital, which they believed was a mental hospital. Our mother left the family when Maicon was very young. She has been out of touch with us, and they thought she might have been treated for mental health problems.

    Maicon agreed to sign himself into the psychiatric unit for treatment. The whole family except I had agreed to have Maicon transferred to a mental asylum. I knew inwardly there was still some plausible means by which my kid brother could overcome this condition. I knew botanical means of treatment will be more favorable than any other type of treatment, and as such, I had taken a keen interest in the research of naturopathic alternative measures suitable for the treatment of schizophrenia. I had pleaded for some little patience from the family in the delay of the transfer, I was looking forward to proving a point to the entire family, of a positive botanical remedy for this condition.

    It was during my ceaseless search on the internet I had been fortunate enough to come across Dr. Utu Herbal Cure: an African herbalist and witch doctor whose professional works had majored on the eradication of certain viral conditions, especially schizophrenia, ( improving the memory capacity positively), via a traditional, naturopathic process and distinguished diet plan. It was by the administration of this herbal specialist that my brother had been able to improve his condition for better.

    Before the naturopathic remedy - Maicon's story had reflected a common case, in which a high-functioning young adult goes through a major decline in day-to-day skills. Although family and friends may feel this is a loss of the person they knew, the illness can be treated and a good outcome is possible.

    My brother Maicon is just like many other patients out there suffering from this disease. Although he was able to overcome this condition via a naturopathic herbal remedy administered by this African herbal physician and saved completely thus, rekindling the lost joy which had been experienced by the family members.

    I wish to use this opportunity to reach across to anyone who may happen to be diagnosed with this disastrous condition to spread the hope of an everlasting herbal remedy that is capable of imposing a permanent end to this disease.

    For more information concerning this naturopathic herbal remedy, feel free to contact this African herbal practitioner via email:
    drutuherbalcure@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete